Cards on the table, I’m a weirdo who actually liked the Finder icon in Tahoe developer beta 1. I think it looked great and was a proper reimagining of the icon I’d been staring at in my dock for the past few decades for the new design system in Tahoe.
I’m with Matt on this one. I can’t believe people are so opposed to change that flipping a color is such a travesty. And if we look at it from a pure design perspective, I think the original one fits better with the liquid glass motif.